AI Answers Send Almost No Clicks — So Why You Still Want to Be in Them

Google’s AI answers barely send any clicks. A real test put the number at about 0.9% — roughly one click for every hundred times a website appeared inside an AI answer.

So should you opt out of AI Overviews and AI Mode entirely? The same test says no — and the reason is surprising.

What the test actually did

SEO specialist Cyrus Shepard took one website and used Google’s own opt-out control to pull it out of AI Overviews and AI Mode. Then he compared traffic from before, during, and after the opt-out.

AI impressions were about 8% of the site’s total impressions in Google. The clicks those impressions produced worked out to an estimated click-through rate of about 0.9%.

That number lines up with independent research. Pew found in 2025 that only about 1% of people who see an AI summary click a link inside it. AI answers are mostly read, not clicked.

The surprise: regular clicks fell too

Here is the part nobody expected. When the site left the AI answers, its regular organic clicks dropped as well. On the pages with the most AI visibility, average position dipped — and then recovered when the AI visibility came back.

Shepard calls it a “SERP halo effect”: showing up in more places on the results page makes a click more likely anywhere on it. When your business appears in the AI answer AND in the regular results underneath, the two seem to help each other.

Read the number honestly

This was one website, and a small sample. The 0.9% is estimated by subtraction, not measured directly. And the AI Overviews themselves stayed on the page throughout the test — so this is not proof that opting out hurts your rankings.

But it is the first real test of the opt-out, and it points the same way as the bigger studies: AI answers send very few clicks, and opting out is not the fix.

What this means for your business

Do not opt out of AI features. Instead, do the things that make Google’s AI summary of your business accurate:

  • Keep your service pages clear and specific about what you do, where you work, and what it costs.
  • Say the same facts the same way everywhere — your website, your Google Business Profile, your listings. Mixed messages confuse the AI.
  • Aim to be cited in the answer AND to rank below it. The two listings together are worth more than either one alone.

AI search will not replace your website. But the businesses that show up in both places — the answer and the results — are the ones customers click.

Questions owners ask

Do AI Overviews send any traffic at all?
Very little — about 1 click per 100 appearances in this test. The value is visibility and trust, not a flood of clicks.

Should I opt out of AI Overviews?
No. In this test, opting out also cost the site regular clicks, and the effect reversed when visibility returned.

How do I get my business into AI answers?
Publish clear, specific pages that answer real customer questions, keep your business details consistent everywhere, and keep your Google Business Profile complete and up to date.

Similar Posts